

* * *
“The first Appalachian Trail Conference [ATC] was called by the Federated Societies, at the request of the Regional Planning Association of America, to take place at Washington, D.C., on March 2 and 3, 1925.”
Thus begins the eight-page, double-spaced typescript titled “Brief of Proceedings of the Appalachian Trail Conference.” The document was prepared by the Appalachian Trail’s conceptualizer, Benton MacKaye, immediately after the conclusion of that gathering at Washington’s Hotel Raleigh just 100 years ago. “The Conference was called for the purpose of organizing a body of workers (representative of outdoor living, and of the regions adjacent to the Appalachian Trail),” the “Brief” continued. “This purpose was accomplished.”
This year, 2025, the non-profit Appalachian Trail Conservancy, as the ATC was renamed in 2005, is celebrating the centenary of its founding, as described at “a new ATC Centennial microsite – keepthetrailalive.org where visitors can learn about the history of the organization, find ways to join the year-long celebration, and get special edition ATC Centennial merchandise that supports our mission-driven work.”
I have contributed articles to ATC publications on previous anniversary occasions marking the history of the Appalachian Trail (AT) and the ATC. (The AT and the ATC, it is worth keeping in mind, are separate entities, though symbiotically and intricately connected.) In 2000, my article “Benton MacKaye and the Path to the First A.T. Conference” appeared in a special issue of Appalachian Trailway News celebrating the organization’s 75th anniversary. Four years ago, in 2021, my article “From Trauma to Dream: Benton MacKaye’s Troubled Path to the Appalachian Trail,” was included in a special issue of A.T. Journeys that commemorated the 100th anniversary of the publication of MacKaye’s 1921 article first proposing the AT, “An Appalachian Trail: A Project in Regional Planning.” As their titles suggest, my more recent 2021 article describes the dramatic events in MacKaye’s life leading up to the publication of his 1921 article, while the earlier 2000 article recounts his role and activities in promoting the AT during the idea’s earliest formative years, between publication of his seminal 1921 article and the creation of the ATC four years later. The substance of these two articles is derived from my book Benton MacKaye: Conservationist, Planner, and Creator of the Appalachian Trail, first published in 2002.
Thus, it is not useful or necessary for me to rehash the same material once again. However, AT enthusiasts, and others, may be interested in MacKaye’s own account of that first meeting of the Appalachian Trail Conference on March 2 and 3, 1925, which, according to an entry in his pocket diary, he completed by March 6. I have transcribed the full text of the “Brief” below, following as closely as possible its original format and punctuation.
For more complete background and context concerning the events and people described in the document, I refer readers to my own publications cited above or to the books of estimable AT historians, such as Brian King’s The Appalachian Trail: Celebrating America’s Hiking Trail (2012), Thomas R. Johnson’s From Dream to Reality: History of the Appalachian Trail (2021), and Sarah Middlefehldt’s Tangled Roots: The Appalachian Trail and American Environmental Politics (2013).
* * *
Brief of the Proceedings of the
APPALACHIAN TRAIL CONFERENCE
Called by the
FEDERATED SOCIETIES ON PLANNING AND PARKS
Hotel Raleigh, Washington, D.C., 1925
The first Appalachian Trail Conference was called by the Federated Societies, at the request of the Regional Planning Association of America, to take place at Washington, D.C., on March 2 and 3, 1925. The Appalachian Trail is a proposed footpath along the crest of the Appalachian Mountain Range from New England to the Southern States. This proposal was made in an article by Benton MacKaye, published in The Journal of the American Institute of Architects (October, 1921). The Conference was called for the purpose of organizing a body of workers (representative of outdoor living, and of the regions adjacent to the Appalachian Range) to complete the building of the Appalachian Trail. This purpose was accomplished.
What the Conference Discussed (First Day)
The first day of the Conference was devoted to various general aspects of the Appalachian Trail project.
Major William A. Welch presided.
Frederic A. Delano, President of the Federated Societies and of the American Civic Association, gave “a word of welcome”. He made the point that the Federated Societies was a federation and not a “combine”,–a pooling of common interests and not a compromise of conflicting interests.
Benton MacKaye outlined the Appalachian Trail project. Its ultimate purpose is to conserve, use and enjoy the mountain hinterland which penetrates the populous portion of America from north to south. The Trail (or system of trails) is a means for making this land accessible. The Appalachian Trail is to this Appalachian region what the Pacific Railway was to the Far West, — a means of “opening up” the country. But a very different kind of “opening up”. Instead of a railway we want a “trailway”.
Like the railway the trailway should be a functioning service. It embodies three main necessities:
(1) Shelter and food — (a series of camps and stores);
(2) Conveyance to and from the neighboring cities, — by rail and motor;
(3) The footpath or trail itself connecting the camps.
But unlike the railway the trailway must preserve (and develop) a certain environment. Otherwise the whole point is lost. The railway “opens up” a country as a site for civilization; the trailway should “open up” a country as an escape from civilization. The railway develops the environment of the hotel and the Pullman car; the trailway should develop the environment of the camp and the “pathless woods”. The path of the trailway should be as “pathless” as possible; it should be the minimum path consistent with practical accessibility.
But railway and trailway, each one is a way, — each “goes somewhere”. Each has the lure of discovery — of a country’s penetrating and unfolding. The hinterland we would unfold is not that from Cape to Cairo, but that from Maine to Georgia.
Mr. MacKaye outlined a suggested policy for the completion of the Appalachian Trail. He based it on the key note set by Mr. Delano — that of federation versus combine.
The projected Trail route, and adjacent territory, was divided into five regions:
New England
New York and New Jersey
Pennsylvania
The Central Appalachian region (Maryland, Delaware, District of Columbia, Virginia, West Virginia)
The Southern Appalachian region (North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama, Georgia)
In each region one or two pivotal sections were suggested to concentrate on:
In New England
Berkshire Section
In New York and New Jersey
Palisades Park Section (Hudson Highlands)
In Pennsylvania
Lehigh Section (westward from the Water Gap)
Susquehanna Section (west of Harrisburg)
In the Central Appalachian region
Shenandoah Section
In the Southern Appalachian region
Great Smokies Section (Tenn. and No. Carolina)
Blue Ridge Section (Carolinas & Georgia)
A local scouting crew was suggested to be organized in each section to carry through the location and building therein of the Trail. Mr. MacKaye made the final suggestion that a Trail service be established in at least one section (or some portion of one section) in each of the five regions, this work to be taken up as a definite piece of construction for completion by the 150th anniversary of the Nation’s birthday (July 4, 1926).
Raymond D. Adolph, Forester of the Palisades Interstate Park, New York and New Jersey, spoke on the “Appalachian Trail as a Fire Guard”. Following (or in conjunction with) the development of the Appalachian project as a “trailway” service it should be developed as a “forest fire protection” service. The Appalachian Trail should be the backbone of such a protection system; it should be from the very start an asset and not a liability in the matter of forest fires.
Mr. Adolph presented an illuminating picture of the possibilities of forest fire fighting on an organized military basis. He showed how last November on Mt. Dunderburg in the Palisades Park, the line of “the enemy” (fire) was outmaneuvered and defeated by the line of men (soldiers and civilians) that were mobilized to meet it. He showed the need of developing a forest fire protection force and the possibilities of interesting the public in fire fighting as a fascinating problem in strategy.
F. E. Matthes, of the United States Geological Service, spoke on the Appalachian Trail as a “Nature Guide Service”. The ultimate purpose of the Appalachian project is to develop an environment wherein the people themselves (and not merely their experts) may experience — through contact and not mere print — a basic comprehension of the forces of nature (evidenced in forest growth, in water power, and otherwise), and of the conservation, use and enjoyment thereof. Through the vehicle of the Nature Guide Service (and possibly an “Historic Guide Service”) some form of field university, — in matters geologic, biologic, historic and the rest — might be evolved which would achieve the vital idea advanced recently by Mr. Chauncey J. Hamlin, namely the development of an “Outdoor Culture”.
Raymond H. Torrey, Field Secretary for the Survey of State Parks, reviewed the work which has been done thus far along the Appalachian Trail route, citing especially the Trail services established by the Appalachian Mountain Club in the White Mountains, by the Green Mountain Club in Vermont, by the Palisades Park Commission in the Hudson Highlands, and by the United States Forest Service in the Central and Southern Appalachian States.
Frank Place, Secretary of the New York-New Jersey Trail Conference, followed Mr. Torrey with a more detailed description of methods used in developing the Trail work between the Delaware and Hudson Rivers.
Fred F. Schuetz, Scout Leaders Association, Newark, New Jersey, spoke on “Tributary Trails”, illustrating the possibilities of making such Trails from adjacent cities along the route by the 45-mile Trail which he and his fellow workers have made connecting the city of Newark with the main route at Greenwood Lake.
Arthur C. Comey, Secretary, New England Trail Conference, spoke on “Going Light”, illustrating his points with many valuable and practicable suggestions as to what the knapsack should, and should not, contain to serve as an instrument and not an impediment in the art of outdoor living.
Clarence S. Stein, Secretary, Regional Planning Association of America, spoke on the history of the Appalachian project, showing how the Association came to take up the project as one in regional planning. He drew the picture of the two extreme environments of our civilization — the city and the crestline. This contrast, in eastern United States, he illustrated by the conception of a possible giant city of “Atlantis” (the merging of the seaports along the short line [sic]), and the conception of the opposite type of environment along the Appalachian mountain hinterland. The further “Atlantis” is developed on the one hand, the greater the need of developing “Appalachia” on the other. Hence the interest of the Regional Planning Association in the Appalachian project.
What the Conference Discussed (Second Day)
The second day of the Conference was devoted to the discussion of the possibilities of developing The Appalachian Trail as a service in the three regions in which thus far the project has been least developed, — in Pennsylvania, in the Central Appalachian region, and in the Southern Appalachian region.
Will O. Doolittle, Secretary-Treasurer, American Institute of Park Executives, presided.
A. E. Rupp, Chief, Department of Forests and Waters, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, discussed the possibilities in Pennsylvania, suggesting that the Trail development be based upon the interesting historic background connected with the Indian land grants to William Penn.
W. McCulloh Brown, Secretary of the Maryland Forestry Association, Baltimore, discussed the proposed alternative routes of the Trail across Maryland, the east side route between Blue Ridge Summit and Knoxville, Maryland, and the west side route which would utilize the tow path of the C & O Canal along the Potomac between the Hancock locality and Harpers Ferry.
G. Freeman Pollock, President, of the Northern Virginia Park Association, Skyland, Virginia, outlined a place for a practicable Appalachian Trail service, from gap to gap, through the northern end of the proposed Shenandoah National Park, based upon a series of camps and stopping places. He pointed out the ready use of such a Trail service by people living in the cities from New York to Washington.
Dr. H. S. Hedges, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, discussed the possibilities opened up by the extension of the proposed Trail service through the southern end of the Shenandoah Park.
Paul M. Fink, Jonesboro, Tennessee, discussed the possibilities of a Trail service in the proposed Great Smokies National Park, pointing out the important fact that this locality is probably the wildest and most rugged piece of country east of the Rocky Mountains.
Clinton M. Smith, United States Forest Service, outlined on the map the Trail system of the Forest Service in the several National Forests in the Central and Southern Appalachian regions, and showed the possibilities of using this system as a basis for an Appalachian Trail service through these Forests.
Hon. John Barton Payne, Chairman National Conference on State Parks, presided at the final luncheon.
Stephen T. Mather, Director of the National Park Service, spoke on Trails in the National Parks, and possibilities of developing a Trail service both in the East and in the West.
What the Conference Did
The business meeting of the Conference was held on Tuesday afternoon (March 3), Major William A. Welch, presiding. At the meeting the following action was taken:
(1) The Conference was made a permanent body.
(2) A provisional constitution was adopted placing, provisionally, the affairs of the Conference in the control of an Executive Committee of fifteen persons, five to be chosen at large and two to be chosen from each of the five designated regions adjacent to the Trail line.
(3) The Executive Committee provided for in the Constitution was elected. This is composed of the following members:
Major William A. Welch, Director of the Federated Societies, and Manager of the Palisades Interstate Park, New York City
Mr. C. S. Stein, Secretary of the Regional Planning Assocation of America, New York City
Mr. Chaucey J. Hamlin, Chairman of the National Conference on Outdoor Recreation, Buffalo, New York
Col. W. B. Greeley, Forester, United States Forest Service, Washington, D.C.
Mr. Arthur C. Comey, Secretary, New England Trail Conference, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Mr. Charles C. Cooper, New England Trail Conference, Rutland, Vermont
Mr. Frank Place, Secretary, New York-New Jersey Trail Conference, New York City
Mr. Raymond H. Torrey, New York-New Jersey Trail Conference, New York City
Mr. A. E. Rupp, Chief, Department of Lands and Waters, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Mr. J. Bruce Byall, Narberth, Pennsylvania
Mr. G. Freeman Pollock, President, North Virginia Park Association, Skyland, Virginia
Dr. H. S. Hedges, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia
Mr. Paul M. Fink, Jonesboro, Tennessee
Mr. Verne Rhoades, Supervisor, Pisgah National Forest, Asheville, N. C.
Major W. A. Welch was elected Chairman and Mr. Verne Rhoades Vice-Chairman of the Executive Committee. Miss Harlean James, of the Federated Societies, was selected as Secretary for the Committee and Mr. Benton MacKaye, of the Regional Planning Association of America, was selected as Field Organizer.
♦